INTERVIEW
WITH SHAKILA RAFIQ
Sohail:
Let
me start my interview from your childhood. What kind of family
environment did you grow up in? What are some of the memories
of your childhood?
Shakila:
I have very many fond memories of my childhood. My family
used to live in Seetapoor, a small town close to Lucknow in
India. I was a small girl when my family immigrated to Pakistan.
There were seven children in the family. I was the second
last. As far as the family environment is concerned it was
quite traditional and religious. My childhood was exciting
but I faced some problems when I became a teenager and those
problems made those years painful.
Sohail: Can
you share something about your parents? What kind of people
were they?
Shakila: My
parents were wonderful people. My dad was really nice. I was
very fond of him. He was a well-read man and was a well-respected
lawyer of his community. He had a good taste in literature
and remembered many couplets of Urdu and Persian poetry by
heart. He was an affectionate and friendly father. My mother
was a loving but traditional woman. She was caring but a bit
naïve. She was not very educated and was simple like
most of the women of her time. There was a special innocence
about her. She was not a very sophisticated woman. She treated
all her children alike without realizing that every child
has a unique personality and needs to be handled in a unique
way. In some ways she was quite strict. When I was hardly
nine she started asking me to hold my dopatta, my scarf, in
a certain way. She did not realize that putting too many restrictions
on a young mind hinder its natural growth. She meant well
but she was not aware of the sensitivities of young minds
and hearts. She was unaware that too much discipline can cause
emotional complications in children's personality. I was more
affected by those restrictions as a teenager because I did
not have any earlier. As a child I was free to do anything
with my cousins. Since most of them were boys, I used to climb
trees with them and have fun. I also remember going upstairs
and jumping from one roof to the other. Because of such mischief
there were times I also suffered. Once when I was staying
with my father's family, I fell from the roof. They lived
in a village so the only way they could take me to see a doctor
was in an oxcart. I was heavily bleeding and my older brother
was trying hard to stop the bleeding by putting the pressure
on my chin. I don't remember the details but I was told all
that later on when I was older. When the doctor examined me
he told the family that I had lost lots of blood. He told
them if I had waited longer I could have lost my life because
of excessive bleeding. There was a big cut on my chin. Looking
back, sometimes I wonder why did they not wait longer, it
might have been better. I still have a big scar on my chin.
As a teenager I realized that I was different than other girls
as I thought very different from them. I wanted to be special
and do special things. In my free time I used to day dream
and build castles in the air.
When India got divided I came to Pakistan with my mom and
started living in Karachi. That is where I started my schooling.
My dad had to stay behind because of family and political
reasons so my older brother took over the family responsibilities
for a while. My brother was a loving but a strict person.
Sohail: How
were you affected by family restrictions?
Shakila: Those
restrictions made me doubt myself and they undermined my self-
confidence. I had many questions in my mind but there was
no one around to discuss them with. In those formative years
small things make a big difference.
From my early childhood I used to love to read. I would get
children's books from the library and read them regularly.
I also enjoyed reading children's section in the newspapers.
In the jang newspaper there used to be a children's page.
The same newspaper also had a children's magazine called bhai
jaan [big brother] Shafi Aqeel used to edit the magazine but
everybody called him bhai jaan. Those were the years I started
writing stories myself by my maiden name Shakila Rahim. Once
I wrote to Shafi Aqeel stating that I wrote stories, He wrote
an encouraging letter asking me to send him my stories but
I was too shy to send. My family never encouraged my creative
expression and I kept all my literary talent locked within
myself.
Sohail: How
old were you when you started writing stories?
Shakila: Nearly
eleven years old.
Sohail: And
how old were you when you finished high school.
Shakila: I
was sixteen. And I had only attended a few months in Sir Syed
College when my marriage was arranged. That arrangement killed
all my hopes and ambitions and dreams.
Sohail: What
kind of dreams did you have as a teenager?
Shakila: I
had many dreams: dreams to be a writer, a girl guide, an actor,
a singer and many more but I had to give all of them up when
my marriage was arranged.
Sohail: Did
they not discuss with you before arranging your wedding.
Shakila: No
there was no discussion. My future was decided without any
consultation with me. One day a woman came to visit us. After
a few days my sister told me that I was getting married to
that woman's brother. I did not ask her anything about the
groom.
Sohail: Why
not?
Shakila: Out
of spite. I thought what was the point. They had already decided
about my future. Luckily my husband Rafiq turned out to be
a thorough gentleman. When he found out that I had a keen
interest in reading and writing, he encouraged me. His encouragement
unlocked my talents and opened the lock that earlier restrictions
had put on my mind. Soon after that my first short story was
published and then many more.
My
husband was liberal in some areas but not in others. He was
neither too narrow minded nor too broadminded. Afterwards
when I had children, it took a lot of my time and I could
not concentrate on my writing.
Sohail: What
happened to those stories that you had written for a children's
magazine?
Shakila: I
still have them
Sohail: Why
were they not published?
Shakila: Because
I never sent them for publication.
Sohail: How
many are they?
Shakila: Four
or five.
Sohail: How
come you did not publish them later on.
Shakila: I
forgot all about them because I started focusing on writing
short stories for adults.
Sohail: When
was your first short story published and in which magazine?
Shakila: It
was a coincidence that my second short story was published
in seep before my first short story was printed in naya daur.
Sohail: What
was that experience like?
Shakila: It
was quite exciting to see my short story published in a literary
magazine. But at that time something else was also happening
in my life and that was quite fascinating.
Sohail: And
what was that?
Shakila: Some
of my stories were published in akhbaar-e-khwateen, women's
magazines and digests. There was a time I used to write for
literary as well as popular magazines.
Sohail: What
made you write for popular digests?
Shakila: They
used to pay me a handsome amount for my stories. As I mentioned
that my marriage was arranged when I had just finished my
matriculation. I had a great interest to read. I remember
once Rafiq suggested that instead of reading literary books
I should read cookbooks. I thought I could read both kinds.
I was upset by his suggestion but I did not have any argument.
Being an Eastern woman I was told to compromise with my husband
to keep peace at home and I followed that suggestion. But
after his death I worked hard to raise my children. To earn
a living I started writing for the popular digests. Pakeeza
used to pay me the most. His editor was very thoughtful. He
helped me a lot in those difficult days.
Sohail: How
old were you when your husband died?
Shakila: Twenty-eight.
After my husband's death both sides of the family offered
financial support but I turned it down. I did not want my
children to be financially dependent on their extended family.
I was afraid it would affect them emotionally. I believe those
children who are dependent on others develop inferiority complex.
I wanted to look after them myself. Children who are looked
after and supported by their own parents become very confident.
In the beginning it was very difficult. It was hard to get
a job because my education was limited. I had only passed
my matriculation. Meanwhile I received an offer from pakeeza
magazine. Since they were willing to pay I accepted their
offer. After that I accepted all those offers of magazines
that were willing to pay.
Those days the issues of survival were so important that I
did not think of making a name in literary circles. I have
met many editors of literary magazines in Pakistan. They offer
complements but no money and you know that children's stomachs
cannot be filled by complements. I was lucky to write for
popular magazines, as I was very confident about my writing
skills. Those magazines had a formula like harlequin romances
and it was not difficult to write many stories in the same
style. To look after my children and pay bills I wrote for
those popular magazines for many years. Later on many literary
critics acknowledged that even those stories had a literary
quality. Those days I was known as a successful writer of
popular magazines. They needed me and I needed them. We complemented
each other.
Sohail: You
also had an interest in enhancing your education?
Shakila: Alongside
writing stories I also started studying for my exam. And when
my older daughter appeared in grade twelve exams, I appeared
in those exams too. After Rafiq'a death for the first couple
of years I was in shock and could not focus on anything. I
was a very sensitive person and I used to get upset by small
things. It took me two years to accept his death. After I
recovered I started focusing on books. After passing my intermediate
exam, I started studying for my bachelor's exam and after
passing that I appeared in my master's exam. I was pleased
to get masters in Urdu literature. Sohail, talking about those
times is making me upset as I am remembering all the sad things.
The painful memories are coming to the surface. The most painful
time was the time that I spent with my mother after the death
of Rafiq.
Sohail: How
long was that?
Shakila: Nearly
two years. It was very painful because nobody had told my
mother that Rafiq died. It was kept a secret.
Sohail: Why
wasn't she told?
Shakila: She
was sick and the whole family thought that she would die with
the shock. I did not agree with them. I told them that if
they had a strong faith in God then they should know that
the time of death is fixed. Telling her the news should not
change the time of death but they did not listen to me. Mother
was told that Rafiq had gone to Saudi Arabia to earn a living.
Since we were financially struggling at that time, she believed
them too.
But those days she used to watch me very carefully. One of
my brothers was in Saudi Arabia and his wife used to live
upstairs. In the evening she used to get dressed and come
downstairs to visit us. My mother used to ask me whether Rafiq
called and I responded by saying that he preferred to write
letters than to make phone calls. After Rafiq's death for
a while I stopped dressing up. I used to be so sad I did not
feel like doing anything. One evening my mother said to me,
"Those women whose husbands live and work in Saudi Arabia
wear nice clothes and jewelry. Does he not send you money
and clothes?"
"Yes, he does" I used to lie 'those nice clothes
that I wore the other day were sent by him."
I used to die inside when I told those lies to pacify her.
Every evening I used to feed my old mother with my own hands.
One evening while I was finishing my story for pakeeza as
that day was the deadline, my mother requested me to feed
her. I asked her to wait for a few minutes so that I could
finish the last dialogue of the story. Those days she had
become irritable and used to lose her cool easily. In anger
she said, "I would like to be fed right away. I cannot
wait." And then she lost control, "What are you
doing here. You should go to Saudi Arabia and live with your
husband. I am afraid he might have married another woman.
That is why he does not come to visit. Neither does he send
you any new clothes and jewelry. Even on Eid you were wearing
white clothes and had no jewelry on. That is not right."
I tried to pacify her one last time, "These days wearing
white clothes has become a new fashion.' But I could not take
it anymore. The cup of my patience was spilling over. She
continued, "The husbands living in Saudi Arabia come
to visit their families every three months. Look at your brother.
He comes frequently to see his wife. I think you should go
to Saudi Arabia and live with Rafiq." After listening
that I could not control myself and started weeping bitterly.
I had controlled my tears for two long years. I could not
control them any long. My brother heard my cries and came
running downstairs. He hugged me and when he heard what mother
had said, he could not keep a secret any longer. He told mother
that Rafiq had passed away two years earlier.
When mother heard that news she went into shock and became
speechless for the longest time. Then she held her arms and
I embraced her and we both cried. This was the first time
mother and daughter had an honest expression of feelings and
shared our sadness and grieved about my dead husband. My brother
called the whole family. When they saw that I would not stop
crying they said, "You are crying as if he died yesterday."
I told them, "Today is the first day I shared my grief
with my mother. I will try my best to control my tears. You
don't worry about me." I was not even allowed to cry
then.
It was interesting that mother did not die after listening
the sad news and lived for another couple of years.
Those days I also met a few literary critics who advised that
I should not write for popular digests and focus on literary
magazines to make a name in literature. They did not realize
that buying food, clothes and books for my children was more
important than making a name in literature. But because of
their advice I started writing for literary journals also.
Those stories were hard to write and I had to spend a lot
of time composing their plots. Because of my stories in popular
magazines I was able to survive and those days survival was
very crucial. I wanted to live with dignity and self-respect.
Sohail: For
how many years did you write for popular magazines and digests?
Shakila: Nearly
eight years.
Sohail: How
many stories would you have written in those eight years?
Shakila: More
than hundred.
Sohail: That
is an awesome number.
Shakila: Alongside
writing stories to earn a living I studied for my exams. After
passing my bachelor and masters in literature I applied for
a job and with the grace of God I got a nice job in PIA, Pakistan
International Airlines.
Sohail: What
year was that?
Shakila: 1985.
Sohail: How
many children do you have?
Shakila: Four.
Two sons and two daughters.
Sohail: So
you had been a single mother. What is it like to be a single
mother in Pakistan?
Shakila: It
is not easy. Not only I was young but my daughters became
teenagers too. You being a psychiatrist can imagine what kind
of psychological and social problems a young widow faces in
Pakistan. Men do not respect single women especially when
they become widows. I had to be very discrete and protect
myself. I wished I lived in Canada. Then I would not have
to face the same problems.
Sohail: Did
you have pressure from the family and the community to have
a second marriage?
Shakila: Yes,
I did.
Sohail: Then
why did you not marry?
Shakila: Because
of my children. I had many proposals but I turned them all
down. I thought those men would accept me but they would not
accept my children and I did not want them to suffer. I did
not want my children to deal with a step-dad. I wanted to
look after them myself and sacrifice my life for them.
I also remembered a promise I had made with Rafiq. I used
to ask him that if I died I did not want him to marry again.
I did not want my children to be brought up by a stepmother.
He used to laugh and say, "What makes you so sure that
you would die first?"
I used to say, "I am the one who gets sick off and on."
Then like a child I used to ask him to promise that he would
not die before me. One day he did make the promise but did
not keep his promise and here I was left all alone to look
after four children.
Sohail: How
much was the age difference between the two of you?
Shakila: When
I got married I was sixteen and Rafiq was thirty-two. He was
an affectionate and loving husband so the age difference did
not bother me.
Sohail: How
did he die?
Shakila: He
died a sudden death because of heart attack. He had a family
history of heart problems but before his heart attack he never
complained of any symptoms. He was a healthy man. It was his
first and last heart attack, as he did not survive. It was
a tragic death. He went to bed and had a good night sleep.
In the morning when I went to wake him up
. (started
to sob). Usually he used to wake me up but the day before
we had a lot of household work including whitewashing, so
I thought he was tired so I did not wake him up right away.
I helped the children get ready for school and after they
left home, I got busy with other activities. When the time
to go to office came closer I got a bit worried and called
him to wake him up. I called once, the second time and then
the third time but he did not respond. So I went to the bedroom
and when I touched him, I felt as if I had touched a stone.
Even then I did not think that he was dead. I thought he was
sick and needed medical attention. In the meanwhile the guy
who used to bring eggs and bread every morning knocked on
the door. I asked him to call my neighbor who was a good friend
of mine. After she came and assessed the situation she asked
me to wait in another room and called the doctor. Because
of segregation she told me that other men had also come alongside
the doctor. I stayed in that room for three hours and nobody
told me what was happening. Finally I could not take it any
more and shouted that I wanted to know what was happening.
At that time my friend Zeba gently told me that my husband
had passed away. She tried to console me and asked me to be
patient. I can't tell you how did I cope with that death.
Rafiq's death has been a mystery for me till this day. I will
never be able to get over the fact that my husband was dead
and I was busy getting the children ready for school and doing
household work. I think it was so unfortunate. Recovering
from his death was a great struggle and I had to offer a lot
of sacrifices. I had to crush myself to survive. To survive
I not only had to hide things from others, I had to hide them
even from my own self. I had to deceive myself to cope with
the tragedy.
Sohail: In
the beginning you did not remarry because you wanted to look
after them and did not want to expose them to a step-dad but
after they grew up then why did you not marry?
Shakila: I
did not meet anyone that I thought would be compatible with
me. I pay a lot of attention to aesthetics. My children especially
the oldest daughter wanted me to remarry but
.
Sohail: If
you meet someone suitable now would you remarry?
Shakila: No,
not a chance.
Sohail: Why
not?
Shakila: I
am no longer a marriageable age now.
Sohail: I
don't think love and marriage are bound to any time and any
age. My favourite Argentinian blind writer Borges and popular
South African leader Mandela got married when they were eighty.
Shakila: Alongside
age there is one more reason?
Sohail: And
what is that?
Shakila: I
am so used to my independence now. I enjoy my freedom. Although
I never misused my freedom, yet I feel I can do whatever I
want whenever I want and whichever way I want. I don't want
anyone asking me why did you come so late from mushaira [poetry
recital]. When I live by myself I can read or write in the
middle of the night. I don't want anyone to ask me stop reading
and writing and turn off the light because he would like to
go sleep.
Sohail: But
that is not always the case. There are spouses who respect
each other's privacy and wishes.
Shakila: I
have seen so many couples. The husbands are always interfering
in wife's matters.
Sohail: Some
husbands might be that way. Are you saying that creative life
is affected by marital life?
Shakila: Not
only by marital but also by family life. Responsibilities
for children hinder with creative growth. I believe many writers
only became great and created master pieces because they did
not have the responsibilities of a family life as they lived
alone all their lives. Famous Urdu writer Qurat-ul-ain Haider
and artist Sadeqain are wonderful examples of that group.
Single people can devote their time and energy to their art
and creativity whole-heartedly. There are many things I could
not write because of my responsibilities for my children.
Now I have more time and I am thinking of creating more. If
I was not married I might have been a different kind of an
artist. My life would have been very different.
Sohail: Then
you would not have had children either.
Shakila: Now
you have touched my sensitive note. But if I had never had
them, I would not have missed them. But now my children are
everything for me. They give meaning to my life. I want to
dedicate the rest of my life to them.
Sohail: Let's
go back to your education and creative life. How did you feel
when you finished grade twelve exams after being out of school
for a few years?
Shakila: It
felt good especially because it came so easy to me. After
grade twelve, I did my BA and MA in Urdu literature. Even
doing MA was not difficult. I felt as if I knew the course
already as I had read those books for my personal interest.
At that stage of my life, I needed a degree to earn a living.
So when I passed my masters exam, I got the job.
Sohail: What
kind of jobs have you done?
Shakila: I
started looking for a job after Rafiq's death. When I had
BA I was offered a position of being the Vice Principal of
a school. But I was offered only three hundred rupees salary
per month. I could not imagine doing a full time job and then
coming home to cook and clean for my children. I was struggling
with survival issues. To work the whole month and get only
three hundred rupees was not enough. I chose to write for
Pakeeza digest instead as they were willing to pay me one
thousand rupees [three months salary] for each story. Those
days I could write a story in three or four days. Then I wrote
stories for other women's magazines and digests. This went
on for a few years and then I passed my MA examination and
got a job in PIA [Pakistan International Airlines]. My children
were grown up by then too.
Sohail: What
kind of work did you do with them?
Shakila:
I was offered the job of a Public Relations Officer in the
Administration Department. Those days they used to publish
a magazine by the name of Falak Parvaz. I used to look after
that magazine. I also prepared speeches for the officers and
answered letters. Although I did all the work for the magazine
the manager used to put his name as the editor. There was
also an English magazine by the name of Top Flight. Another
woman used to do all the work and again the manager put his
name as the editor. I tried to give the Urdu magazine a literary
touch by including poems and short stories and interviewing
some of the staff. In spite of injustices of the mangers,
I tried to enjoy my job to the best of my abilities.
Sohail" For how long did you work there and then why
did you leave that job?
Shakila: I
worked there for seven years and when I received immigration
visa for Canada, I decided to move here. I did not want to
leave my job right away so I applied for leave without pay
for two years but my application was turned down. Because
of my obligations I had to resign.
Sohail: What
kind of obligations?
Shakila: I
wanted to leave my options open. I was not sure how would
I feel in Canada and whether I might want to go back and work
again in Pakistan. But my boss did not let leave the door
open, so I had to close it against my wishes. It was a painful
time but with the grace of God everything turned out to be
okay.
Sohail: You
have passed your masters in Urdu literature. What do you think
of the progressive and modernistic movements in Urdu literature?
Shakila: It
is a general impression that to be a progressive writer you
have to denounce God and religion and embrace socialism. But
I do not believe that to be progressive one has to be an atheist.
The progressive period in Urdu offered literature a new taste
and colour and a new style to create. Short story writers
did some novel experiments. Some writers were more successful
than others. I believe in new experiments as they open up
new avenues but I am not impressed by all kinds of experiments.
I never liked those abstract stories of modernistic literature
that have a communication problem as I believe in communication
and I do not consider those stories successful in which communication
between reader and writer breaks down.
Sohail: How
did your style of writing changed after you did your masters
in literature?
Shakila: I
did my masters as a mature student. It was done to get a degree
and a job. I had already studied those books because of my
personal interest and passion. After I got a job and my financial
situation was secure, I stopped writing for digests and started
writing for literary magazines and to do that I focused more
on my craft, the topic and developed my own style to write
short stories. In that way doing masters indirectly affected
my writing style. I don't know how successful I am as a writer
as the reader is the final judge but I believe that learning
is a lifelong process and I feel good that I am still learning
and growing.
Sohail: When
did you immigrate to Canada?
Shakila:
I came to Canada in 1986 for the first time and then I visited
a number of times until I finally moved in 1998.
Sohail: What
are your views about the Western lifestyle?
Shakila: I
have mixed feelings. Some aspects I like, others I don't.
I like that people in the West do not lie and cheat and take
bribes in their day-to-day lives. They act on most of the
good advice of our religion. Their religion tells them the
same things but they act on them. In the East we do not follow
our religious values. In the West people get the reward for
their labour. That is why they have a more just and peaceful
lifestyle. The aspect that I don't like is their immodesty.
But that is part of their culture. My like or dislike does
not matter.
Sohail: What
are your views about those Eastern people who are living in
the West?
Shakila: They
are facing a lot of problems. Those people want their children
to be introduced to the Eastern values and life-style, which
is very difficult. But it might be difficult but not impossible.
I have met a few families who have been successful in this
regard. Children who grow up in the West get in conflict between
Eastern and Western values and lifestyles. Many of those children
only speak English and do not speak their mother tongue. And
I feel that when children do not learn their mother tongue
they are deprived of their tradition, religion and culture.
Some children understand Urdu but always respond in English.
I believe Asian parents should speak to their children in
their mother tongue.
Sohail: What
are your views about dating in the West?
Shakila: The
tradition of dating has not become successful even in the
West. During the daytime when I am home I watch talk shows
on television. In one of the shows I saw a six year old with
his mother and four men. They were going to declare the results
of the test to tell the little boy, which one of those four
men was his biological father. In the end we found out that
none of those men were his father. So the boy discovered that
the man he believed as his father was not his father. Now
you tell me as a psychiatrist how that little boy's mind and
personality would have been affected. At the end of the show
the host asked the little boy, "What would you become
when you grow old?" He said, "A good father".
I think this is the end result of dating.
Sohail: Are
you suggesting that as compared to the tradition of Western
dating the Eastern tradition of arranged marriage, in which
the bride and the groom had not even seen each other before
marriage, is better?
Shakila: I
think for marriages we can make a formula. In the West many
couples live with each other for years and when they get married
they get divorced after a few months.
Sohail: So
then what do you suggest how should people get married?
Shakila: I
think we need not put too many conditions on the institution
of marriage. Marriage should be based on love, sacrifice and
compromise. I don't agree with the bride and groom not seeing
or meeting each other before marriage. I think there should
be mutual liking.
Sohail: An
American philosopher Joseph Campbell in one of his interviews
stated that in the past human relationships were decided by
tribido in which the tribe decided the future of the romantic
relationships of the future generation. In modern times tribido
is replaced by libido in which young people fall in love with
each other and then get married. West has adopted the tradition
of love marriages while in the East we still have the tradition
of arranged marriage. When I was living in Iran, I was quite
pleased that parents had accepted that their grown up children
will date and chose their own life partners. In Persian they
had words pisr doast for boyfriend and dukhtar doast for girlfriend.
In Urdu we do not have such words, as we have not accepted
the social reality of dating. In Pakistan mothers feel that
it is their right to choose grooms for their daughters. Do
you agree with such tradition?
Shakila: No,
I am not in agreement with any such tradition. By the way
all Eastern mothers are not like that. Some give their children
the choice to choose their partners of life. I am one of them.
I follow my religious tradition. Our religion tells us that
we should consult the bride and the groom and do not go ahead
without their consent. The young couple has the right to choose
but they do not have the right to make all of their decisions
and exclude their parents and families. Young people delude
themselves that they are intelligent and wise and they know
it all but the reality is not like that. Do you think at that
age they are smart enough to make all the right choices about
their lives?
Sohail: We
are not talking about all the choices of their lives. We are
focusing on the romantic choices. I believe that romantic
love is a pre-condition for marriage. My parents had not even
seen each other before they got married. They were not attracted
to each other and they were not in love before they got married.
Their families met each other and decided about the future
of their grown up children, which turned out to be a disastrous
marriage. I do not agree with such marriages in which there
is no love between the spouses. In Pakistan if a young woman
tells her family that she loves a man she is perceived as
a loose woman.
Shakila: I
don't agree with that tradition. I think in our religion a
woman has every right to like a man even propose to him. Its
best example was Bibi Khatija who proposed to Prophet Mohammad.
We have traditions that are not part of the religious traditions
and I do not agree with them. Those conservative religious
leaders who are not aware of the depth and meaning of our
religious tradition promote them.
Sohail: In
the West romance is respected and love is celebrated. In the
East they are not.
Shakila: I
am not against love. In the East men have love marriages with
only those women that they can control. In the East men are
in power, they have the authority. It is a patriarchal society.
Sohail: Does
it mean then that you are not against dating?
Shakila: I
am in agreement of young men and women meeting and liking
each other but I am not in favour of pre-marital sex.
Sohail: What
do you think of women's rights in the West?
Shakila: In
the West women take advantage of their rights. Western women
have gone on the other extreme. When Eastern women come to
the East and learn about their rights they exploit their husbands.
Such exploitations end in disastrous divorces.
I am also critical of how young men and women in the West
treat their older generation. They do not look after their
elderly parents. Eastern children are adopting the same attitude,
which I do not like. I feel Eastern children growing up in
the West are not only losing their tradition, religion and
culture, they are also losing their respect for the elders.
The only time they remember their parents and grand parents
are Mother's and Father's day. It is also unfortunate that
Eastern children cannot communicate with their grandparents
who cannot speak English. Without a common language relatives
become strangers.
Sohail: You
have published a number of books. Can you tell me something
about them?
Shakila: My
first novella dard hay apna saathi was published in 1976.
My first collection of short stories kuch dair pehlay neend
say was published in 1987.
My second collection khushboo kay jazeeray was published in
1989.
My third collection qitaar main khara aadmai was published
in 1998.
In 2001 I published Ismat Aapa. A long time ago I had conducted
a detailed interview with the legend of Urdu literature Ismat
Chughtai. After doing a lot of research I weaved the interview
with my research and wrote that book. That book was liked
in many circles. Numerous Urdu, Hindi and English newspapers
and magazines in India and Pakistan positively reviewed it.
In 2002 my sixth book Aasman talay was published which was
also my collection of stories. Now I am preparing for my seventh
book, which will consist of English translations of my short
stories.
Sohail: As
a writer how do you feel living in Canada?
Shakila: I
feel like a stranger here. I miss my literary activities and
creative friends of Pakistan. But I have a learnt a lot too.
Living in Canada has broadened my intellectual horizons.
Sohail: Your
readers consider you a successful writer. What is your own
view about your accomplishments?
Shakila: In
the preface of my book I have acknowledged that readers are
the final judges for a writer. If they think I am successful
then I feel successful. That is my ultimate criterion.
Sohail: Do
you have any regrets?
Shakila: I
have only one regret but I cannot share that with you. It
is very private.
Sohail: Do
you have any unfulfilled desire or dream?
Shakila: I
wished I were a successful poet.
Sohail: Why
is that?
Shakila: I
believe a successful poet can say in one couplet in poetry
what takes a dozen pages to say in prose.
Sohail:
Did you ever compose poems?
Shakila: Yes,
I did. But people did not know about it. My first poem main
aur too[I and You] was published in Jang newspaper in Karachi.
Some of my poems were published in Shair a respectable Urdu
magazine of India. I have been writing poetry since 1976 but
most people are not aware of it. They see me as a short story
writer.
Sohail: Did
you create in other literary genres?
Shakila: Yes,
I wrote light essays [inshaiays] also. Professor Afaaq Siddiqi
recently compiled my unpublished writing in a book called
shakila rafiq
fun aur shakhsiat[Shakila Rafiq
art
and personality].
Sohail: What
would you call a writer who is a successful poet as well as
a successful short story writer?
Shakila: I
will call him Khalid Sohail (smiles)
Sohail:Thank
you for the complement and thank you for sharing your thoughts
and life experiences with me.
Shakila: You
are quite welcome.
..
Dr.
Khalid Sohail